So this is an attempt to structurise what I have learnt over the past four years and see if I can develop some sort of decision tree or a checklist to value a stock.
Investing is the last liberal art for a reason. You can value a stock to the last decimal and feel happy about it but the market can create its own price movement and you’re left flummoxed as to what is wrong with you. A lot of subjectivity is included and what matters the most is whether you can see a light bulb glowing and say- Aha! You must be able to visualise the future reasonably well, at an early stage,buy large enough and hold it long enough for thr story to play out.
As I say, find a reason to say no to a stock within five minutes. So let’s see what can help us in this aspect. Too much debt, capital intensive industries with no clear difference in product( construction etc) are a clear no for me. I will say no to a stock also if I can’t understand and reasonably explain a business model to someone who doesn’t have anything to do with investing. This allows me to negate a lot of ideas which can possibly block my capital.
Now the first and foremost checkpoint is if the company has a reasonable possibility to be alive after 10, if not 20 years. To find such companies, I look for companies which have been around for the past 30-50-100 years and are still going strong. HUL, Colgate, Reliance, ITC etc are all in this category. This helps me avoid the new new things which glitter a lot today but can fade in no time tomorrow.
Second, find companies which you believe can not just be alive but thrive in ten-twenty year’s time in India. This means, you’re inherently betting on a growing India and investing in companies which will grow bigger as India does. So anything which is not going to be profitable as India grows richer, eliminate all of them.
Third, if the company ticks the above two, find out if it can grow by investing more capital or less capital or basically no capital. A company like say a Bank or Larsen will definitely grow but it’s going to need a lot more capital to increase its balance sheet and to generate those profits. However, the companies which need this capital may also raise fresh equity capital leading to dilution of current equity, which means my shares are at a risk of being diluted to the extent of fresh equity raised. It’s a red flag for me. Also, if the company raises fresh debt capital and the market goes south, I might be staring at a potential bankruptcy. So a no no to me.
However, if there are companies which can grow reasonably well with India without raising fresh capital, you’re staring at a multi year multibagger story. The profits will rise but since the number of shares remain constant, the market capitalisation will only rise even taking into account a very high dividend payout. This is what I love. The brokers, the AMCs, the stock exchanges, HUL, ITC etc are all in this category and this is what I’m buying. The price movement can be anything in the meantime, but if you can hold them long enough, for 10+ years, you’re bound to be proven right.
Now comes the question of how to value a company which ticks all these boxes and if it should be bought or not. You’ve eliminated close to 80% of the market by these three checkpoints. So on a piece of paper, write out the name of a stock and dig down deep. See what can you understand about it and have the following in mind:
Sit down calmly and read the annual reports for the past three years and contemplate whether the story is getting clearer or not. If you’re still convinced, then ask yourself what according to you a similar company in US would be worth. This has helped me to calculate the runway ahead of us as the real destination of all capitalistic society is at WallStreet. So when I looked at valuations of NYSE and NASDAQ, it allowed me to believe that one fine day, if BSE can even become one tenth of what NYSE is, it can be valued North of $7 billion. When I valued ICICI securities, I looked at what Charles Schwab was doing in a quarter and realised that our brokers can do ten times more profits than today in ten years and still they’ll have more to go ahead of them.
This is how I’ve tried to build stories in my head. Once you’ve the story in your head loud and clear, you stop worrying about the price fluctuation and focus only on annual performance, that too over three year blocks. This is how conviction is built and you get the courage to hold.
PS: read Nick Sleep’s letters, available to download on Google and trust me, this man’s a genius!